Milling System Puts Productivity In Fast Lane

When this company won a contract to machine automotive parts for a customer, they were faced with the need for a milling tool that could meet tighter cycle times, enable machining centers to perform multiple tasks, maximize the life of milling tools and reduce tool inventory.

Case Study From: 4/15/2002 Modern Machine Shop

Click Image to Enlarge

Cast iron cutters

From left to right: Scott MacLaren, an NPP manufacturing engineer, Tim Marshall, Kennemetal product manager and Tom Van Order, Kennametal field sales representative, observe the surface quality that the Fix Perfect cast iron cutters provide on a housing cover.

Cast iron milling system

In machining an inter axle differential case, NPP replaced a solid carbide end mill, which lasted 2 days, with the Fix Perfect cast iron milling system. In doing so, NPP was able to reduce already-tight cycle times and increase tool life from 2 days to more than 2 weeks.

Housing cover

Surface finish and flatness are two critical requirements of this housing cover. They are achieved using Kennametal's Fix Perfect cast iron face milling system with 3-inch diameter cutter and KY3500 ceramic inserts.

Nationwide Precision Products (Rochester, New York) specializes in the precision machining of complex castings and components. When the company won a contract to machine automotive parts for a customer, NPP was faced with the need for a milling tool that could meet tighter cycle times, enable machining centers to perform multiple tasks, maximize the life of milling tools and reduce tool inventory.

The company selected the Fix Perfect cast iron face milling system from Kennametal. Depending upon the application, this cutting tool can accommodate eight-edged carbide inserts or KYON 3500 ceramic cutting tools for high speed applications and high metal removal rates. To produce higher feed rates, the inserts are tangentially positioned in the cutter head at 20 degrees or 0 degrees.

"We tested a lot of milling systems on our shop floor, and none was better than Fix Perfect," says Dave Merritt, NPP's director of manufacturing engineering. "The Kennametal cutting tool lasted longer and performed better than competing products. KYON 3500 ceramic inserts cut metal like a hot knife going through butter. With Fix Perfect, we have accelerated cycle times by about 45 percent and are saving $100,000 in labor costs annually."

Since March 2000, NPP has been successfully using the Fix Perfect cast iron face milling system with KYON 3500 ceramic inserts in the rough and finish milling of various parts for a manufacturer of truck and automobile axles.

"NPP has to mill many parts in short time frames," says Tom Van Order, a Kennametal field sales representative. "Before NPP agreed to purchase Fix Perfect, we worked very hard to simulate production line conditions during the testing phase. During testing, Fix Perfect exceeded the customer's expectations, and it continues to do so on the shop floor."

Each Fix Perfect cutting insert has eight cutting edges that each provide about 110 minutes of tool life, or 880 minutes of tool life per insert for NPP's applications—much longer than the average useful life of similar tools. Each insert, which is secured to the cutter head by a clamping screw, cuts the metal surface at programmed intervals.

"The difference is unbelievable," says Mr. Merritt. "We were using solid carbide end mills that lasted for a few days on a particular application, but the Fix Perfect system lasts us several weeks, which allows us to fulfill the objectives we had at the beginning of our search for a milling system." Those goals included meeting tight cycle times, using machining centers to perform multiple tasks, maximizing the tool life of the inserts and reducing tool inventory.

The Fix Perfect system can be used in horizontal and vertical machining centers. The inserts can reach speeds of 3,000 rpm and require no lubricants, because the cutting tool speed is fast enough to create the friction required to move the correct amount of metal.

One of the parts that NPP mills with the Fix Perfect system is an inner axle differential case made of medium tensile ductile iron (SAE #4012) that is welded together to house "spider gears" in motor vehicles. The differential case is milled on a Mori Seiki SH-403 horizontal machining center, which is a 25 hp 40-taper machine. The milled surfaces are four trapezoid-shaped ridges that protrude from the ring of the differential case. Each metal protrusion is milled by a coarse pitch cutter head, which has a 3-inch diameter and contains 8 KYON 3500 ceramic cutting tools.

"The performance of Fix Perfect in this particular application shows that the product works just as well in ductile iron applications as it does in cast iron ones," says Tim Marshall, product manager for the Fix Perfect line. "Generally, ductile iron is more flexible than cast iron. Nevertheless, ductile holds up extremely well when milled by fast-moving Fix Perfect cutting tools."

NPP is also using the cutting tools effectively in milling the interior perimeter of a cast iron housing cover (SAE #4012) that is used to protect rear axle tractor-trailer gears from overheating and loss of lubrication.

"The effectiveness of this application shows that Fix Perfect performs equally well in horizontal and vertical machining centers," says Mr. Van Order.

The pumpkin-shaped housing cover is finish milled on a Mori Seiki SH-403 vertical milling center, which is almost identical to the machine that mills the differential case. As in the horizontal milling application, the cutter head with KYON 3500 ceramic cutting inserts moves while the metal remains stationary as it is being milled.

"With Fix Perfect, our productivity on milling the housing covers has improved dramatically," says Mr. Merritt.

Besides using Kennametal's Fix Perfect to mill the differential case and housing cover, NPP is milling a carrier housing and a bearing cap that is bolted to the housing.

"The Fix Perfect cast iron milling system has exceeded our expectations," says Mr. Merritt. "It's clearly a product that does what the manufacturer says it will do—and more."

Mr. Merritt is so pleased with Fix Perfect that he has invited Kennametal to field-test any new metalcutting and machining products that the company invents.

Comments are reviewed by moderators before they appear to ensure they meet Modern Machine Shop’s submission guidelines.
blog comments powered by Disqus
LEARN MORE

Related Suppliers

Kennametal Inc.

Zones

Supplier Categories

Loading the player ...
Drilling, routing, milling, reaming.
AMAMCO Tool engineers custom tooling for your most critical applications.
ERIX tool saves up to 90% of the manufacturing time on back spotfacing and chamfering operations.
MMS ONLINE
Channel Partners
  • Techspex