Steve Kline, Jr. has been providing financial analysis and economic forecasts for Gardner Publications, Inc. (publisher of Modern Machine Shop) since 2005. While he has a degree in civil engineering from Vanderbilt University and a MBA with an emphasis on finance from the University of Cincinnati, Steve views forecasting as more of an art than a science. Therefore, his analysis focuses on trends between different data sets to determine where the economy (and, more importantly, the metalworking industry) may be headed. The study of economics is his life’s passion, hence the T-shirts of his favorite economists. Yes…any time he wears these, his wife points out that he truly is a geek.
With a reading of 50.7, Gardner’s metalworking business index showed that the metalworking industry expanded for the first time since March 2013. The index was 9.0 percent higher than it was in October 2012 and it was the second straight month of month-over-month growth. And, it was the fastest rate of growth since June 2012.
New orders grew for the first time since March 2013 and at their fastest rate since May 2012. Similarly, production grew for the first time since May 2013 and at their fastest rate since May 2012. Backlogs continued to contract, but they did so at their slowest rate since February 2013. After two months of contraction, employment grew in October Exports continued to contract as the dollar remains relatively strong. Supplier deliveries continue to lengthen at similar rate to the last 12 months.
Material prices increased at a similar rate to most of 2013. Prices received barely increased in October, which is similar to the rest of 2013. Future business expectations shot up in October, reaching their highest level since May 2012.
Shops with more than 50 employees have been expanding throughout most of 2013 and that trend continued in October. Shops with fewer than 50 employees have contracted throughout 2013. However, the rate of contraction has moderated the last couple of months. Shops with fewer than 19 employees had an index of 49.2 in October compared to 40.2 in August.
While nine regions had contracted for three months, in October four regions expanded. The Mountain region had an index of 60.2. New England grew for the second month in a row. The South Atlantic and West North Central region moved to expansion from contraction. The East North Central, Middle Atlantic, and Pacific regions were just under 50. The East South Central continued to contract the fastest but it did see a significantly slower rate of contraction compared to August.
Future capital spending plans were up 6.3 percent compared to last October. This was the second month in a row that the month-over-month rate of change grew.
With a reading of 48.1, Gardner’s MBI showed that the metalworking industry contracted at a much slower rate in September. The index was 3.2 percent higher than it was in September 2012. This was the first time the month-over-month rate of change grew since April 2012.
While every subindex moved lower in August, in September each moved higher and contributed to the slower rate of contraction. New orders reached its second-highest level since March. Production barely contracted, reaching its highest level since May, and the backlog subindex was also near its highest level since March. Employment, exports and supplier deliveries also contributed positively to the overall index. Employment barely contracted for the second month, exports contracted at a slightly slower rate, and supplier deliveries lengthened for the third straight month.
Material prices increased at a constant rate in September. Prices received moved to modest growth from very modest contraction. Future business expectations also improved but are still at their second-lowest level of 2013.
One of the most important reasons for the slower contraction was the significantly higher index for facilities with fewer than 50 employees. These small shops have seen bad business conditions throughout 2013. While they still contracted in September, the index for small shops reached its second-highest level since March.
All nine regions had contracted for three months, however in September, New England grew and the Mountain region remained flat. The East North Central and Middle Atlantic saw minimal contractions. The West South Central contracted faster for the second month, and the East South Central remained the poorest-performing region with its second month in a row of an index below 40.
Future capital spending plans were up 3.0 percent compared to last September.
With a reading of 44.6, Gardner’s metalworking business index showed that the metalworking industry contracted at its fastest rate since November 2012. Since leveling off at the end of 2012 and beginning of 2013, the industry has generally contracted at an accelerating rate since March 2013.
Perhaps the most significant reason for the accelerated contraction in August was the decline in performance at facilities with more than 50 employees. These facilities had been growing throughout 2013. But, in August there was a noticeable drop in business activity. Shops with more than 250 employees contracted for the first time since December 2012. And, facilities with 50-99 employees contracted for just the second time in 2013. The smallest shops, those with fewer than 19 employees, saw their fastest rate of contraction since we expanded the survey in December 2011.
Every single sub-index moved lower in August. New orders and production dropped significantly, almost matching their fastest rates of contraction at the end of 2012. Backlogs have been contracting since March 2012. Employment contracted for the first time since November 2012. Exports contracted at their fastest rate since December 2012. Supplier deliveries were lengthening, but at a much slower rate.
Material prices continue to grow but the rate of growth has slowed from earlier in 2013. Prices received were just below 50 in August. This is the first time prices received have decreased since December 2012. Future business expectations fell to their lowest level in 2013.
All nine regions were below 50 in August. And, all nine regions had a lower index reading in August than they did in July. The best performing region was the West South Central and the worst performing region was the East South Central.
Future capital spending plans were the lowest since February 2012 and almost 25% below the historical average. Compared to one year ago, spending plans have contracted each of the last five months, but the rate of contraction has slowed each month. However, respondents to our capital spending survey, which you can read more about in the December issue, were very positive regarding their 2014 capital spending plans.
With a reading of 48.5, Gardner’s metalworking business index showed that the metalworking industry contracted at a much slower rate in July compared to June. While the industry has contracted every month but one since July 2012, the trend line of the index has been moving up since November 2012. The index is improving because better business conditions are spreading to smaller facilities.
Throughout 2013, I have highlighted that business conditions were split between large and small shops. Metalworking facilities with more than 50 employees have been growing while those with fewer than 50 employees have been contracting. In July, facilities with 20 to 49 employees began growing for the first time since March 2013 and only the second time since October 2012. These shops grew at their fastest rate since August 2012. Therefore, in July the index showed significant growth in all facilities with more than 20 employees. But, shops with fewer than 19 employees are still mired in contracting business conditions. In fact, business conditions at these small shops contracted at the second fastest rate since April 2012 when this cycle of contraction began.
Two of the sub-indices, employment and supplier deliveries, indicated expanding business conditions in July. Employment has been growing since December 2012 while supplier deliveries have been lengthening every month but one since at least December 2011. All of the other subindices that make up the metalworking business index continued to contract in July but all of them contracted at a slower rate, which is a positive sign. The index level for new orders, production, and backlog made a significant jump in July compared to June. The improvement in the index level for exports was more modest.
Material prices continue to grow faster and faster each month while prices received are growing at a relatively constant rate. However, the growth in materials prices is much faster than the growth rate for prices received, which puts pressure on profits. Future business expectations continue to move in a generally upward direction.
While all nine regions contracted in June, three regions expanded in July. The fastest growth was in the West South Central followed by the Mountain and West North Central. The West North Central has been the strongest region in 2013, growing in five of the last seven months. All other regions contracted with the poorest performance in the Middle Atlantic. This region has been the poorest performing region throughout 2013.
Future capital spending plans remained relatively modest. Compared to one year ago, spending plans have contracted each of the last four months, but the rate of contraction has slowed each month.
With a reading of 48.5, the MBI showed that the metalworking industry contracted slightly in April after growing in March. Since the noticeable contraction in the second half of 2012, the industry has been virtually flat.
The real story through the first four months of 2013 is the diverging performance across plant sizes. Facilities with more than 50 employees have grown in every month. Those with fewer than 50 employees have continued to contract, however, and facilities with fewer than 19 employees continue to contract at the same rate they did in the second half of 2012. Primarily, it is small job shops that pulled the index back below 50.0 in April. Shops dedicated to specific industries are showing much better performance in the first four months of this year.
New orders contracted for the first time since December 2012, and this was the most significant reason the index moved below 50.0. Production, however, continued to grow, albeit at a slower rate than in March. These subindices contributed to the faster contraction in backlogs, but there is likely also some over-capacity in the metalworking industry. This would further explain why backlogs have contracted since April 2012 and why smaller job shops are performing worse than shops dedicated to specific industries. Employment continued to grow in April, while exports continued to contract. Supplier deliveries continued to lengthen, but at almost the slowest rate since August 2011.
Material prices are still growing, but at a much slower rate than the previous two months. Prices received were virtually flat. The combination of these two trends, contracting new orders and growing employment continues to put pressure on profits at metalworking facilities. Future business expectations dropped in April, but they are still above almost every month since July 2012.