Choosing a single master or dual master air gaging system can be difficult. Understanding the similarities and differences--in performance, price and philosophy--can help a user make the best choice for their application.
Modern Machine Shop, George Schuetz
This is a continuation of last month’s column, which examined single master air gaging systems. To read the previous column, click on the link under “Editors Picks.”
Click Image to Enlarge
Last month we began discussing the difference between single and dual master air gaging systems with the emphasis on single masters. This month we’ll look at dual master systems.
First, let’s summarize: Single master systems have the accuracy built into both the air tooling and the air gage display. This means that during manufacture, both the tooling and display are set to precisely known pneumatic characteristics. This makes the tooling a little more expensive, and the displays are fixed to work only with pneumatically matched tooling. Building the system this way enables a single master to set the air gage to its true pneumatic zero. Thus, using the laws of physics, the linearity and performance of the air gage are known.
The other method of building an air system is to use two masters to set the span or gain of the pneumatic system. Rather than use air tooling made to known and fixed characteristics, the user sets the tooling and air gage display so that the span displayed on the readout matches the span between the minimum and maximum setting masters. Setting up the air gage with two masters sets the sensitivity of all components of the air gaging system simultaneously. This allows the displays, air flow restrictors, regulators, air hoses and air jet nozzles to all work together to display the master values.
Dual master air gage displays are typically built around an adjustable back pressure system in which a mechanical or electronic display monitors the change in back pressure that results when the air jet from the tooling is restricted as it approaches the surface it is measuring. This system will usually have two user controls to adjust for the desired span as indicated on the masters.
The problem with many of the older mechanical air gages out there is that these two controls—one for span and one for zero—must be used simultaneously to achieve the required span. With a little practice, this process becomes second nature. For “newbies,” however, the process usually requires a lot of sweat and a few harsh words to get the desired span. The difficulty is that the controls do not act individually but react to each other. This means you have to work both controls together to achieve the target span. An old gaging tip associated with this process says: “Span too tight, turn to the right.”
With today’s electronics, this process has become much easier. Some electronic air gages still use the two-knob system to get the air display close to the right value, then let the electronics lead the operator through the mastering routine to fine-tune the last few tens of millionths. Newer air gage displays eliminate the manual controls altogether and have enough range on the air transducer to allow it to work with most air tooling. The air display then leads the operator through the process of entering the minimum and maximum master values.
Just as there were good and bad characteristics with the single master system, the same applies to the dual master process:
• The slightly higher air pressure cleans light oils and coolants from the part.
• The air flow restrictors and adjusters are easily accessible and can be cleaned if they get contaminated.
• The system has fair linearity.
• The magnification of the air displays are adjustable, so they can be used with many different ranges of air tooling.
• The gages will accept almost any brand of air tooling, and the set points of the masters can be adjusted—although in some cases linearity may suffer.
• The units use two masters, which are easily traceable but add to initial cost.
• The response is good.
• The long hoses slow the response of the air tooling, but this can still be calibrated.
• The dual master systems can be used with small and large jets, allowing for either short-range, high-tolerance applications or longer-range, loose-tolerance applications.
• The customer is not tied down to any one manufacturer because many make tooling for dual master, back pressure air-circuit-type gages.
The biggest weakness of using a dual master system is that while the end points of the gage span are set with the two masters, what is happening in between is not known. If data collection is critical and used for real process control, linearity around the target spec is the most important. This is where dual mastering has a slight disadvantage compared to a single master system.
Whichever system you choose, what is most important—aside from the technical quality of the system itself—is the application and technical support you get from your supplier. That’s where the real benefits and savings are seen.