Dealing With A Spot Drill’s True Point Position

A spot drill has a 90-degree point angle, which makes it easy to calculate the depth of a hole to be spot-drilled. You simply divide the diameter of the spot-drilled hole.

Columns From: 5/1/2007 Modern Machine Shop,

Click Image to Enlarge

A spot drill has a 90-degree point angle, which makes it easy to calculate the depth of a hole to be spot-drilled. You simply divide the diameter of the spot-drilled hole. If you have drilled a 0.25" diameter hole and want a 0.031" chamfer on the hole, the diameter to be spot drilled will be 0.312". The spot-drill depth, 0.156" is half of this.

If this is the method you’re using to determine spot-drill depths, you’ve probably noticed that the chamfer on the hole is a bit large. The larger the spot drill, the larger the chamfer. Why is this? It is because the true point has been “ground off” the spot drill during sharpening. While the spot drill does have a 90-degree angle, the point of the tool that you actually touch during tool-length compensation measurement is not the true point of the spot drill. The drawing below illustrates this.

As you can see, the tool tip that is used for tool-length measurement is not the true point of the spot drill. Again, the larger the spot drill, the greater the difference will be. To precisely machine the chamfer to its intended size on the first try, you must deal with this difference.

How do you deal with this problem? I offer two ways, depending on how many programs you’ve already created using the simple formula mentioned above (spot-drill depth is half the chamfer size).

If you already created many programs, you probably won’t want to go back and change them all. You can deal with this problem during tool-length measurement. On the other hand, if have very few programs to deal with, you should deal with the problem in the program. Frankly, you’ll make life easier for setup people and tool setters if your programs include compensated spot-drill depths. This would be my first choice, but I can understand your concern at having to change hundreds of previously created programs. I’ll offer a compromise a little later.

How much do you compensate? Fortunately, the amount of deviation will remain pretty consistent for a given spot-drill size. Here are four spot-drill sizes along with the difference between the true point and the tip of the tool:

0.375" diameter: 0.026" deviation
0.500" diameter: 0.035" deviation
0.750" diameter: 0.045" deviation
1.000" diameter: 0.060" deviation

For example, if you are using a 0.500" diameter spot drill, and your tool setter measures the tool length compensation offset value to the tool tip, the correct depth to machine a 0.312" chamfer will be 0.121" (0.312" divided by 2, minus the 0.035" deviation).

Handling the problem during tool setting. By one means or another, the person determining a spot drill’s tool length compensation value must consider the deviation amount. If measuring the tool’s length, the operator must increase the tool length compensation value by the deviation amount. One way to do this is to simply measure the tool’s length in the usual manner and then add the deviation amount. Another is to provide the tool setter with one shim for each spot drill size that can be used during the tool length measurement. If measuring tool-length compensation values at the machine, similar techniques must be used.

Handling the problem in the program. Again, this is my preferred method because it doesn’t require any intervention for shop people. Obviously, the programmed depth for spot drilled holes must reflect the deviation. This may not be as difficult as it might seem at first because most programmers use canned cycles for spot drilling. It’s likely that only one word per program must be changed (the Z value in the spot drill’s G81 command).

Another way to handle the problem is to use a G10 command to increase the offset value by the deviation amount. This means the tool setter will measure to the tool tip, and your programs need not change. However, the offset changing G10 command must be executed only one time (obviously, it is changing the offset value for the spot drill).

Comments are reviewed by moderators before they appear to ensure they meet Modern Machine Shop’s submission guidelines.
blog comments powered by Disqus
MMS ONLINE
Channel Partners
  • Techspex