This plastics industry manufacturer relies on machines from Toyoda to produce twin-screw extruders and other production equipment in-house. This strategy saves the company money and enables it to respond flexibly to changing market conditions, among other benefits.
Modern Machine Shop, Matt Danford,
Click Image to Enlarge
With a 5-meter X-axis stroke and a 2.1-meter Y-axis stroke, the LB521 bridge mill is the largest Toyoda machine at SCC. The fourth-axis Tsudakoma rotary table enables the machining of various extruder screw forms and features in a single setup.
With a variety of machined forms, this extruder screw is one of the most difficult parts SCC machines. This picture, however, was not taken at the company’s facility, but at IMTS, where Toyoda used the screw to show off the capabilities of its SB216 bridge mill and Tsudakoma fourth-axis rotary table. This model is similar to but slightly smaller than SCC’s LB521 bridge mill.
Michael Stritner, SCC lead man, deburrs extruder parts produced on the FV1165.
This housing section, a typical part at SCC, is mounted in the shop’s FA630 HMC. Combining multiple sections creates a set of long, tapered, intersecting bores.
When it comes time to replace critical equipment, Standridge Color Corporation (SCC) rarely has to worry about late deliveries, faulty components or shoddy service. That’s because most of the machinery the company uses to produce the color concentrates, compounds and other plastics-industry products that constitute its core business is manufactured at its in-house machine shop. This strategy also provides the flexibility to try out new equipment designs and make alterations without having to deal with outside vendors, says owner and founder Bob Standridge.
Of course, the primary benefit of in-house production is cost savings, which amount to more than enough to justify the cost of the machining centers used for this work, Mr. Standridge says. Although these machines vary by make and model, the company relies primarily on equipment from Toyoda (Arlington Heights, Illinois) for manufacturing its most critical equipment, the twin-screw extruders used to mix various polymers and additives. When asked why he has stayed loyal to that builder since installing the first of its machines more than a decade ago, Mr. Standridge cites two critical factors: “The first is dependability,” he explains. “Their uptime is better than the other brands we have. The second factor is dimensional stability. It might take three cuts on another machine to remove the same amount of metal as one cut on a Toyoda.”
SCC traces its roots to 1980, when Mr. Standridge left a larger firm that performed similar work after recognizing an untapped market in smaller plastic industry manufacturers. The business grew one order at a time, and today, Mr. Standridge oversees seven U.S. plants as well as one in Europe and one in China. The twin-screw extruders and other equipment used at these locations is produced at the company’s headquarters in Social Circle, Georgia. That facility contains a 44,000-square-foot machine shop outfitted with approximately $6 million worth of machining and fabricating equipment, including six Toyoda machines.
The beginnings of this manufacturing operation, however, were much more modest, starting with a few toolroom machines to perform repairs in the early ‘80s. The shop’s first experience with CNC occurred when it retrofitted a large manual lathe to start producing its own extruder screws. It purchased its first “true” CNC equipment, two VMCs, in 1995.
Those machines served well at SCC—in fact, the last was retired earlier this year—but not in the role for which they originally were intended. The company realized soon after purchasing them that it would need a heavier duty machine to effectively process certain twin-screw extruder components. “We make some very large parts, and we need machines that are rugged and stable enough to remove more metal per hour than a lighter duty machine,” Mr. Standridge says.
Some gearboxes and barrel assemblies, for example, are cut from blocks that might weigh as much as 5,000 pounds. In addition to being large, most components are made of steel alloys that are difficult to machine even before undergoing heat-treating, nitriding or chrome-plating operations. Performing the heavy facing, drilling, boring and other operations these parts require would be time-consuming without the proper equipment.
Although SCC doesn’t have the same throughput concerns as a dedicated machine shop might, it still benefits from moving as fast as it can, Mr. Standridge says. In 1997, after evaluating models from several different builders, SCC settled on a Toyoda FA630 HMC. The company purchased a second FA630 in 1999, and in 2001, it brought in a larger HMC, an FA1050. Success with this equipment led the company to turn again to Toyoda in 2009, a year when it sought additional manufacturing capacity to replace worn, outdated extruders throughout all of its facilities worldwide. That round of machine tool purchases included a third FA630 HMC, this one with an upgraded control and other new features; an FV1165 VMC, a smaller, C-frame machine; and an LB521, a large, bridge-type VMC. Both of the latter VMCs are equipped with fourth-axis Tsudakoma rotary tables.
While these machines play different roles in SCC’s manufacturing process, all have proven themselves adept at removing as much material as possible in as few passes as possible, Mr. Standridge says. He attributes this to their sturdy construction. “In most cases, these machines weigh about 25 percent more than comparable machines we’ve used from other manufacturers, and most of that weight is in the casting,” he explains.
One operation in which this rigidity is on full display is the machining of extruder screws on the LB521 VMC, Mr. Standridge says. After being turned to size on a lathe, the screws move to this machine’s fourth-axis rotary table for final-geometry machining. While this enables cutting various features in one setup, much of the work requires sufficient dimensional stability to cut away from the part’s axial centerline. “For a long, round piece like an extruder screw, you would normally want to move the tool down directly on top of it, from the 12 o’clock position,” he explains. “But for some of what we want to do, we might move it down at about 2 o’clock. This tends to try to shift that table to one side, but it doesn’t budge.”
The Toyodas not only take heavy, demanding cuts, but do so with very little downtime, Mr. Standridge says. While admitting that SCC doesn’t run its machines nearly as often as most companies that perform metalcutting as their primary business, he points out that the Toyodas require noticeably less maintenance than other models employed at the in-house machine shop. The shop’s first machines from this builder, the two FA630s purchased in the late ‘90s, are a case in point, he says. The only problem they have experienced in more than a decade of use was an electrical issue that resulted in a burned out drive motor, which had nothing to do with the construction of the machine.
The Toyodas’ spindles stand up especially well compared to other machine brands on the shop floor, which require relatively frequent attention for problems with bearings, drive belts and other spindle-assembly components, Mr. Standridge says. And if one of the Toyoda’s were to experience a spindle issue, it would be easier to fix because all of that builder’s machines incorporate removable spindle tapers, he notes. Another area that causes headaches with machines from other builders is leaky through-spindle coolant systems, typically a culprit of heat from the cut causing a coolant-through cutting tool to expand. This is especially problematic when the coolant eats into the spindle drive belt, an issue that requires “taking the machine half apart” to fix, he says. In contrast, the Toyoda machines employ direct-drive or directly gear-driven spindles rather than belts, and they feature a refrigeration system that prevents tools from expanding in this way.
The nature of SCC’s in-house machining work doesn’t require particularly high part volumes, tight tolerances or short turnaround times. Nonetheless, the Toyoda machines’ reliability and stability ensure that the company can reap the benefits of in-house production without distractions. As a result, SCC will likely consider that builder again when it seeks to add to its machining capabilities—a scenario that is virtually guaranteed as the company continues to incorporate new developments in extruder technology and moves to replace worn equipment, Mr. Standridge says.