DN Solutions
Published

Safe, Smart, Sustainable, Stable — Dispelling the Manufacturing Myths

Manufacturing has had a bad rap for a long time. The 3-Ds — Dark, Dirty, Dangerous — are almost a universal cultural belief wherever you go and no matter with whom you speak. 

Share

The 3-Ds — Dark, Dirty, Dangerous — are incredibly out of date, inaccurate and are being replaced in online conversations, at the very least, by the 4-Ss. I first heard of the 4-Ss when I was listening to Jason T. Ray’s Podcast, Safe, Smart, Sustainable and Stable. (Jason T. Ray is the president of one of PMPA’s affinity partners, Paperless Parts.) In that episode, Michael Tamasi, CEO at PMPA member AccuRounds, was the guest. When I called Michael Tamasi to get the credit right, he said that he had “borrowed” the phrase 4-Ss from Bill Berrien, CEO at PMPA manufacturing member Pindel Global Precision. So the challenger to Dark, Dirty and Dangerous is out and about online. Let’s take a look at the 4-Ss of Precision Machining.

Safe

Then: Dark, Dirty, Dangerous  (Photo from the personal collection of Cate Smith)

Then: Dark, Dirty, Dangerous (Photo Credit: Photo from the personal collection of Cate Smith)

Our industry recognizes its responsibilities to protect the safety of our employees. Our companies value our performers and want to keep them safe. In addition, there is no advantage in losing their performers’ skills through on-the-job injury or illness. We continue to find ways to continuously improve our operations and safety, as well as the technologies we deploy and the training of our performers. Currently, our shops are leading the way with new LED lighting, improved ventilation and even climate control systems. Improved housekeeping is a natural consequence of our adoption of Lean and 5-S methodologies for organizing our operations. The new equipment we install has the latest in interlocks and CNC controllers. Cobots — collaborative robots that are safe for working around humans without guarding needed — are currently being adopted in many of our shops. 

Now: Safe, Smart, Sustainable, Stable (Photo credit: Cox Manufacturing in San Antonio, Texas)

Now: Safe, Smart, Sustainable, Stable (Photo credit: Cox Manufacturing in San Antonio, Texas)

Safety has always been a priority in our industry — as we have consistently been an important supplier for many human safety-critical parts used in transportation (anti-lock brake parts, passenger restraint system components and airbag componentry), aerospace, medical equipment and devices (including implants such as bone screws), gas and electrical appliances, and a host of other important applications. Without our performers, these safety technologies would not exist and the world would be a less safe place. Safety is part of our operations, as well as an important driver of markets for the products of our talented performers.

Our first S — Safe — dispels the “Dark” and “Dangerous” Ds of the 3-D manufacturing myths.

Smart

Our industry is highly automated and computerized, and the technology requires “smarts” while reducing the manual aspects which come to the minds of many when thinking of our industry. In quality control alone, we routinely use optical non-contact measurement systems to characterize and validate multiple features on critical parts — in a single operation. Coordinate measuring machines — operated from a controller much like that of a video game — can use ruby and garnet probes to help determine complex geometric relationships between features and locations. Our performers become knowledgeable about the properties of different materials, tool materials and tool coatings based on chemistry and other treatments, and often use non-destructive testing to assure quality or conformance to requirements. Our formal quality systems support our smart processes to help us deliver parts at rates in the parts-per-million range. 

The 3-Ds — Dark, Dirty, Dangerous — are incredibly out of date, inaccurate, and are being replaced in online conversations, at the very least, by the 4-Ss.

Our engineering and process experts create process routings to ensure the highest quality and least waste — helping us to provide the greatest value. Precision machining careers are smart — and in reach without a college degree. Our latest shop hourly wage survey showed typical operator and set up operator wages exceed Real Median Personal Income in the U.S. (MEPAINUSA672N) by over 20%!

Sustainable

Wages that exceed the median personal income are one aspect — and an important one — of being sustainable. But our industry and shops have always been a leader in recycling the materials in our operations. We not only recycle the chips and solids, but also isolate waste streams from packaging as well. 

We are implementing Internet of Things technologies to help us to better understand energy usage in our shops, and every job that is produced is reviewed for both an efficiency and material yield-loss (mass balance) determination. These determinations help us to identify opportunities for improvement and minimize waste. 

Stable

As a result of our performance in the areas of Safe, Smart, and Sustainable, our shops have created another S — we are Stable. The average length of membership in PMPA across all of our manufacturing member shops is 25 years. Of course, many of the companies are older than this. But durable goods must be made, industrial production goes on, even in bad times, and the precision machined components that our shop and talented performers manufacture are critical to that output. As a result, our smaller, family-owned, closely held precision machining companies find themselves in an enviable niche for the production of highly engineered, often human safety critical, necessary to the function components across many industries, markets and applications.

That stability translates to job security for our employees as well. Even during the Great Recession (December 2007-June 2009 in the U.S.) we had shops advertising for operators. During the COVID-19 crisis, while the broad economy was shut down, our shops were deemed essential manufacturing and several of our members took the lead in producing ventilator parts needed for health care to deal with the crisis. 

That stability is earned by our safe, smart and sustainable performance. In compiling this year’s annual shop hourly wage survey, our participating shops made up just 2.2% industry’s establishments — yet produced shipments of over 5.4 % of the total industry’s sales. We are thriving. We continue to offer great opportunities for people to join our industry to join us on our journey to sustainable success.

Manufacturing — Safe, Smart, Sustainable, Stable

Manufacturing — in particular, precision machined products manufacturing — exemplifies the 4-Ss of Safety, Smart, Sustainability and Stability. If you, or someone that you know has had more than their share of volatility uncertainty, complexity and ambiguity in their life, perhaps you can show them that our industry is a far cry from the 3-D shops that their grandparents called manufacturing. We have great careers in safe shops, using smart technologies sustainably and proven stability for our talented performers.

Safe, Smart, Sustainable, Stable — this is how we describe the shops of the Precision Machined Products Association. What are YOU looking for?


Read More Articles from PMPA:

About the Author

Miles Free III

Miles Free III is the PMPA Director of Industry Affairs with over 40 years of experience in the areas of manufacturing, quality, and steelmaking. He helps answer “How?, “With what?” and “Really?” Miles’ blog is at pmpaspeakingofprecision.com; email –  mfree@pmpa.org; website – pmpa.org

Koma Precision
Gardner Business Intelligence
Hurco
MMS Top Shops
The view from my shop.
DN Solutions
Kennametal
Techspex
World Machine Tool Survey
SolidCAM
Mazak Multi-Tasking: Your Parts Multiplier.
IMTS 2024
Paperless Parts
Precision grinding & hard turning custom solutions
VERISURF
Gravotech

Related Content

Top Shop Builds Upon Employee Ownership for Future Success

In its quest to become the Fox Valley’s best-in-class employer, A to Z Machine has adopted an ESOP, expanded benefits and invested in apprenticeships.

Read More
SPONSORED

How to Grow the Business with Real-Time Job Status Data

ERP systems that focus on making data more accessible can improve communication within a shop, reducing wasteful errors and improving capacity.

Read More
Turn/Mill

A Career at the Top Helps Rebuild a Job Shop

A new approach to management propels expansion into Swiss-type and multitasking machining work.

Read More

If the Federal Government Is to Solve the Manufacturing Labor Shortage, it Needs to Start Here

Student-run businesses focused on technical training for the trades are taking root across the U.S. Can we — should we — leverage their regional successes into a nationwide platform?

Read More

Read Next

3 Mistakes That Cause CNC Programs to Fail

Despite enhancements to manufacturing technology, there are still issues today that can cause programs to fail. These failures can cause lost time, scrapped parts, damaged machines and even injured operators.

Read More
Vertical Machining Centers

The Cut Scene: The Finer Details of Large-Format Machining

Small details and features can have an outsized impact on large parts, such as Barbco’s collapsible utility drill head.

Read More
Paperless Parts