Die Makers Adapt to Challenges All Machine Shops Face
Die shops offer examples of adapting to the skills shortage and excelling at difficult machining. Plus, why reshoring should begin with die tooling.
An example of a die maker significantly rethinking its processes and system is Otto Engineering. Find a link to our article about this shop below.
When I find myself in the position of explaining CNC machining to an outsider — that is, explaining what a machine tool is and how it connects to metalworking and manufacturing — I typically point to a metal component such as a car part to make the point that parts such as this are made by machine tools precisely cutting metal.
However, that explanation overlooks an important step. For many production parts, CNC machining makes the die tooling, and it is this die that makes the part. Given the variety and volume of parts produced through stamping, forming and other die-dependent processes, machining’s use in die making is an important aspect of the role machining plays. And an underappreciated one.
Indeed, die making is often underappreciated even when we give consideration to tooling. Because dies and molds are closely related, “die/mold machining” is routinely lumped together as a single category. But molds are most commonly associated with plastics while dies are for metal. Part of a younger industry and one that is still advancing more quickly, mold making is the flashy newcomer of the tooling scene.
Perhaps it is time for dies to get their due.
Recognizing this, we’ve recently posted a selection of pieces that reflect an appreciation for die machining. It is an appreciation that is well-deserved, as these posts describe how die making is leading the way in facing extreme versions of challenges that all machine shops confront.
One of these challenges relates to skilled personnel. How do shops deal with the now-familiar fact that employees with machining skill and experience are scarce? Consider: While machining skill is scarce, die making skill is rarer still. Otto Engineering responded to this fact by reinventing its process to use die-making specialists only where those employees can deliver the most value.
Then, there are the challenges of the machining itself. A die is an assembly of precision metal components that sees rigorous service — high forces at high frequency. Surface hardness is often a critical requirement. That hardness poses machining challenges for die makers equal to or beyond those of most other shops. Die maker and fineblanking specialist Feintool illustrates one response, describing the system it has found for not only achieving effective hard milling, but doing so within a process expected to run lights out.
Finally, there are important concerns around die making that are bigger than any shop. Our consideration of the topic now could not be more timely. As we’ve covered in recent issues, the disruptions of 2020 have turned attention to supply chain vulnerabilities and the value of reshoring vital manufacturing. Yet any discussion of reshoring must begin with tooling, the vital enabler to production that, over the last two decades, has increasingly been made overseas. A nation in control of its manufacturing must produce its own tools. We recently produced a video to bring greater attention to this very point: a discussion among experts making the case for the importance of domestic tool manufacturing. Watch that video, and please share it, because a very good outcome of a heightened appreciation for die making would be assuring that the U.S. remains strong and gets stronger in this capability.
This shop sees no long-term threat in the reality of lower prices. Machine tool investments related to various die components allow the shop to use skilled labor more efficiently.
Hard milling allows mold components to be machined in the hardened state, thus skipping several expensive and time-consuming processes such as electrical discharge machining and hand polishing.
With many 3D milling applications demanding both shorter cycle times and smoother surface finishes, it’s time to review how you go about programming and machining parts. These four strategies will let you rough dramatically faster and achieve astonishingly fine surface finishes.