| 3 MINUTE READ

Choose the Correct ID/OD Gage for the Task

Benchtop and portable comparator gages each have their place, but the differences are more than surface deep. 
#qualitygagingtips

Share

Facebook Share Icon LinkedIn Share Icon Twitter Share Icon Share by EMail icon Print Icon
An image of a shop employee measuring a part

Circles are a frequently produced form in the shop. Many different processes generate this form — including turning, milling, centerless grinding, boring, reaming and drilling — and there are a variety of gaging methods used to measure inside and outside diameters (ID/ODs) of these circles. For simple operations, shop employees can measure a hole with a scale or a fixed go/no-go gage. For more complex operations, employees can use precision measuring machines like coordinate measuring machines (CMMs) and optical or vision machines. However, in production environments, employees can accurately measure most ID/ODs using one of several varieties of comparator gage.

Comparator gages for ID/OD come in two basic styles: benchtop and portable. Operators with shopfloor level skills should use these gages in high-volume, high-performance applications. Because these gages provide a comparative measurement, they require a master to set the zero reference point when determining part deviation. Comparator gages have limited travel, but this allows the use of a high resolution dial or digital indicators and high resolution electronic probes with amplifier readouts.

Choosing whether to use a benchtop or portable gage will depend on the size of the part being measured and whether the user will bring the part to the gage or the gage to the part. Typically, benchtop comparative gages work best for small parts and are generally restricted to measuring single dimensions or features that are less than 255 millimeters (~9 inches) in diameter and not more than 25 millimeters (~1 inch) deep. Portable ID/OD gages can go as large as 2,500 millimeters (~8 feet) and as deep as 125 millimeters (~5 inches). If a manufacturer needs to go deeper than that, bore or plug gages are a better choice.

Benchtop Gages

Benchtop gages are capable of higher precision than portable gages, with resolutions of 0.0005 millimeter (0.00002 inch) readily achievable. Typical of these are the “plate gages” seen in the bearing industry or anywhere that requires fast readings of ODs or IDs. The tilting stage plates are used to set and locate the part each part and this basic design has been around for more than 50 years. Plate gages are convenient for fast, comparative gaging of flat, thin-walled parts, such as bearing rings. In these applications, users must make diameter measurements in a plane parallel to at least one of the faces, and sometimes at a particular depth on the ID or OD. Versions are available for 2-point or 3-point measuring that allow for the checking of parts that have form errors with even or odd numbers of lobes.

Portable Gages

If the part is large or awkward to manipulate, or if measurement requires setting it up on a machine, use a portable, beam-type gage. Beam-type gages are available with maximum capacities from 25 mm (~1 inch), to about 1100 mm (~40 inches), the largest ones being used to measure bearings and large bores in casting. Actual measuring range is typically 10 mm (~0.4 inch), but is ultimately determined by the indicator installed.

Most portable ID/OD gages lack centralizing stops and require “rocking” like a bore gage to find the true diameter. When rocking the gage, use the fixed contact as the pivot and allow the sensitive contact to sweep across the part. Likewise, if the gage must bear its own weight against the part, make sure the fixed contact bears that weight, not the sensitive one.

Do not expect high precision readings with a portable gauge when measuring dimensions of a foot or more. Most indicators on these large-capacity gages will have minimum grads of 0.01 millimeter (or 0.0005 inch). This is adequate, given the inability of most machine tools to hold tolerances much tighter than about 0.05 millimeter (or 0.002 inch), for parts that large. Beware of the gage claiming to measure more than 900-millimeter (or 3-foot) ID/OD capacity with 0.001-millimeter (or 0.00005-inch) resolution — the gauge is probably not capable of repeatable measurements.

To accelerate and potentially improve the gaging process with portable gages, users can replace mechanical dial indicators with a digital indicator that has dynamic capabilities. This enables the gage to capture minimum or maximum readings or calculate the difference between the two. This also frees operators from having to carefully monitor the motion of a rapidly swinging needle on a dial indicator when rocking a portable gage or checking for deviation on a benchtop version.

 
 
 
 
 

RELATED CONTENT

  • Raising the Bar with Ballbar Testing

    Few manufacturing companies rely on ballbar testing to maintain machine tool accuracy as thoroughly as Silfex. Now, advanced training and a move to a Renishaw QC20-W wireless system have enabled the company to take the benefits of ballbar testing to a higher level.

  • Measuring Part Geometry On The Shop Floor

    Measuring workpiece dimensions is relatively simple for machine operators but measuring workpiece geometry which involves more complex comparisons of part shape to an ideal shape--is now also practical on the shop floor. The gaging equipment for doing this is coming down in price while becoming easier to use.

  • 3D Scanning: Reproducing One-Of-A-Kind Prototypes

    A laser scanning system helps this shop capture the free-form surfaces on a hand-sculpted original. The resulting digitized models are the basis for CAM applications such as programming a CNC machining center.