Expanded Anti-Pullout System Enables Secure Titanium Milling with ER Collet Systems
Because of the extreme forces involved in machining titanium and other hard metals, it is necessary to take precautions to avoid pullout—the tendency for a cutting tool such as an end mill to gradually loosen in its holder and possibly be twisted out entirely.
Because of the extreme forces involved in machining titanium and other hard metals, it is necessary to take precautions to avoid pullout—the tendency for a cutting tool such as an end mill to gradually loosen in its holder and possibly be twisted out entirely. Pullout creates a hazardous situation for the operator, the machine and the workpiece. In the case of large, complex titanium workpieces, damage from a loose cutting tool can be costly. Risk of injury to an operator is certainly an even more compelling concern.
Rego-Fix (Indianapolis, Indiana) has expanded its Securgrip anti-pullout toolholding system so that it can be used with toolholders accepting ER 32- and ER 40-style collets. When originally introduced, the Securgrip system offered specially designed collets compatible with its Powrgrip mechanical toolholding system. These collets provide an extra margin of tool clamping security by locking the collet and cutter to the toolholder via a small, profiled, locking key insert that fits into a standard Weldon end mill flat. This method helps counter pullout tendencies during milling of materials in which optimal machining parameters produce high torque forces on the cutter. Titanium, for example, usually requires an aggressive depth of cut at relatively slow spindle speeds to “bite into” this material for productive metal removal.
The outer profile of the hardened steel Securgrip insert has ridges that are essentially segments of a thread pattern. The back side of the insert profile matches that of the Weldon flat, and the thread pattern on its exposed side matches those of internally threaded Powrgrip system collets. Users hold the insert in place while sliding the tool into the collet. The collet is turned so that its threads engage with those of the insert, and the tool is then screwed all the way into the collet. In operation, the rotation of the spindle and the threads turn in the same direction, thus pushing the tool against the built-in back-up screw.
This cutter-collet assembly is pressed into a Powrgrip system holder, and a special external cap nut is tightened onto the holder for added pullout security. The expanded Securgrip system now applies this internal thread form to ER collets available from the company, enabling a standard colleted toolholder to attain the same level of secure gripping.
Currently, other anti-pullout systems exist in the market. What sets the system from Rego-Fix apart is that it does not require custom modifications to the tool shank, says David McHenry, senior product engineer. Such custom modifications require the cutting tool supplier to obtain a license to adopt the proprietary geometry of an anti-pullout system, which can add cost and delays to cutting tool procurement. The Securgrip enables the use of any off-the-shelf cutting tool with a common standard Weldon flat on its shank.
Users of the expanded collet system must make a one-time investment in the special ER collets with the matching Securgrip internal thread form, however. The system is designed to enable shops to use their existing ER holders and ER nuts. The system works with standard carbide or high speed steel end mills 0.5 to 0.79 inch (12.7 to 20 mm) in diameter, and provides TIR of 0.0002 inch or better, the company says. A backscrew enables presetting of tool length. The locking inserts are sized specifically for the shank diameter. The system is applicable for use with ER 32 or ER 40 holders in all tapers, including CAT, BT, TC, HSK, and Capto, as well as Rego-Fix 0.75-, 1.0- and 1.25-inch milling chucks in CAT, BT and HSK tapers.
Shops participating in the highly competitive field of machining titanium aerospace parts can justify the investment in machine tools with the rigidity and high horsepower at low rpms suitable for titanium. Effective anti-pullout measures ensure that these shops do not have to retreat from the optimum machining parameters these machines can deliver because of concerns about the security of the cutting tools and toolholder assembly.
A tooling system consisting of interchangeable cutting units and standardized locking units has a lot to offer users of CNC machines, whether for turning, milling, or both on a turn mill. These guidelines will help you think clearly about how modular, quick-change tooling can benefit your shop.
Collet toolholders are too important to the machining process to use them incorrectly. Follow this simple advice.
The force that holds the toolholder in the machining center's spindle can weaken over time. If you haven't checked drawbar force in a while, this may be the weak link in your process.