Flexible Grinder Streamlines Drive Shaft Production
When a bottleneck arose from an application involving multiple setups, this shop invested in a new grinding machine with a full B-axis. Since then, it has consolidated the troublesome operation from three machines to one.
Twin Disc, a manufacturer of marine transmissions, grinds shafts of all lengths, weights, shapes and sizes. According to the company, the only thing all these shafts have in common is precision—very close tolerances and unforgiving surface finishes. Flawed shaft production can result in transmission failure. Thus, Twin Disc strives to use the best grinding technology available. So, when a bottleneck arose from a labor-intensive shaft-production process involving multiple setups, the company invested in a new grinder equipped with a full B axis. Since then, it has consolidated the troublesome operation from three machines to one.
Based in Racine, Wisconsin, Twin Disc has been in business for more than 75 years making more than 30 different marine transmissions for pleasure craft, military vessels, tugs, pushboats and more. In fact, Allied forces depended on the company’s transmissions to drive some 40,000 landing craft loaded with troops and supplies onto beaches during the Normandy invasion and throughout the South Pacific during World War II. In addition to marine vessels, the company makes transmissions for mining industry trucks and for various military vehicles, including the Bradley armored personnel carrier.
The two plants in Racine have a combined 551,271 square feet of manufacturing space and about 400 employees. The company uses a total of 21 cells, 14 of which are manufacturing cells for milling, turning, grinding, drilling, finishing and other such operations. The others are used for assembly, process completion and so forth. The company performs all operations except heat treating in-house.
The drive shafts are produced in 10 different diameters with various tapers. The shafts range from 8 to 48 inches long, with diameters ranging between 0.5 and 10 inches. The company holds tolerances between 0.0002 and 0.001 inch and surface finishes from 10 Ra to 40 Ra. Materials include 1144, C1144, 4145, 4140 and 8620 steel alloys as well as some stainless. Order quantities range from a single shaft to 500 pieces.
The company had been looking for a process change in the production of transmission shafts. Two grinders were used to grind the straight ODs, and a third was used for plunge grinding tapers. Terry Andersen, grinding team leader, programmer and machine operator, says this was a slow, operator-intensive process. Shafts had to be refixtured from the OD grinders to the plunge grinder. To improve productivity, the company wanted a grinder with a full B axis to combine the processes in a single machine.
When the company began searching for a flexible grinder to do shaft work in one shot, everyone was “a little leery,” Mr. Anderson says. There weren’t many manufacturers to choose from, and certain shaft dimensions eliminated some right away. At one point, the company actually acquired a grinder with a full B axis. However, the machine wouldn’t hold diameter size or taper tolerance and was not consistent, leading the company to continue with the old method.
“There was another company that was just coming out with a full B-axis machine, and they maintained they could accommodate our specs, tolerances, surface requirements and shaft dimensions, but we decided against it,” Mr. Anderson says. “This was going to be their first machine of this type, and frankly, no one wants to be anyone’s guinea pig—especially when you couple this with our previous experience.”
Eventually, the company settled on the Kellenberger Kel-Varia cylindrical grinding system with the Heidenhain GRINDplusIT control. A key factor in the company’s acquisition of the machine was its ability to hold tight tolerances while grinding tapers. On many shafts, the taper is nothing more than a press fit. Most of the tapers’ surface requirements are 40 Ra, but some have an angle of 30 to 1, which is less than a 1-degree taper.
“We had to have a machine that could handle that kind of range of demand,” Mr. Anderson says. “It had to be flexible, agile, rigid, and above all, repeatably consistent in holding very tight tolerances.”
The machine’s hydrostatic guideways are designed to provide accuracy and avoid friction and stick-slip movement. It features absolute measuring in the B axis, incremental, distance-coded scales in the X and Y axes and a high-resolution C axis. The grinder can also be equipped with a second B axis for more dimensional stability and profile accuracy.
The B axis permits automatic positioning of the wheelhead at any angle. For positioning accuracy, it includes a precision worm gear and distortion-free clamping. A Hirth coupling, which indexes at 2.5 degrees, also contributes to positioning accuracy. The Kel-Set automatic grinding wheel measurement system enables automatic movements to the measuring ball and to the grinding system, and it stores position information to the control system. When swiveling the wheelhead into any angle, the system automatically accounts for the positions of the wheel edges. In addition, the option of interpolating the X and C axes allows grinding of non-round shapes such as polygons, free contours and eccentric forms. For various types of grinding operations, the machine can use universal, diagonal and tandem-type wheelheads.
The grinder’s Heidenhain control features a Windows 2000 operating system, a graphics editor, expanded grinding cycles, intermediate dressing at the push of a button, comprehensive tool management, several reference points for each grinding wheel, remaining-travel display and more.
“The Kellenberger not only met all our requirements, but it was a proven machine, so we didn’t have to worry about working the bugs out of a new design,” Mr. Anderson says. “It’s been very reliable, and most important, it holds tolerances and surface finishes with remarkable repeatability.”
Because the company runs as many as 1,200 different shafts, change-over and setup are very common. However, according to Mr. Anderson, the new grinder makes this easy.
“Depending on what’s involved, we can changeover from shaft to shaft in about 10 minutes, especially if we’re not changing centers, and it’s strictly a matter of moving the tailstock and changing the driver,” Mr. Anderson says. “If you need to change centers and drivers, then you may be up and grinding in 20 minutes or less.”
About a year after purchasing the first Kellenberger, Twin Disc bought a second. With the exception of a hydraulic tailstock to handle even heavier shaft work, the second machine is identical to the first. The two machines reside in a single cell, and one operator runs both.
“We’re able to run twice as much product as before,” says Gary Pope, plant manager. “One operator does two shafts at once, and they come off finished. We run these machines 6 days a week, 24 hours a day, and we’ve already seen improvements in productivity. The accuracy and repeatability couldn’t be better.”
Optimizing a camshaft lobe grinding cycle has traditionally been based less on science and more on educated guesswork and numerous test grinds. Now, computer thermal modeling software can predict areas where lobe burning is likely to occur, in order to determine the fastest possible work speed that won't thermally damage lobes and greatly reduce the number of requisite test grinds.
If one must pick a manufacturing specialty, grinding carbide might not be the first choice because it’s perceived to be very difficult. RPM Carbide Die, however, has worked the material for nearly 40 years and, as specializing seems increasingly to be the order of the day, this northern Ohio shop is in a good position to thrive.
No other process can do what creep-feed grinding can do. Recent tests show even more can be gained by optimizing every element of a creep-feed system.