Shop Uses HMC to Become Serious Contender
By investing in horizontal machining centers, L.B.G. Machine was able to increase the productivity necessary to take on high-precision work.
It would have been a waste of time to quote multifaceted jobs on his existing vertical machining centers (VMCs), says Gene Heisner, owner of L.B.G. Machine Inc. (Allentown, Pennsylvania). According to Mr. Heisner, his company simply could not have produced the parts anywhere near as efficiently as it did once he purchased a horizontal machining center (HMC) from Doosan Infracore (Pine Brook, New Jersey). Since implementing HMCs, the company has increased its efficiency, and in turn, increased its competitiveness.
From starting L.B.G. in his garage 25 years ago to meeting a 21-employee payroll today, Mr. Heisner has been on a path of continuous improvement. In fact, he recently had the opportunity to grow his job shop business by bidding on two long-term contracts in 2012. The first bid was to provide five- and six-sided machining for various hydraulic components, and the second was to produce a high-finish, close-tolerance, prismatic gas-well part from 718 Inconel.
In order to be a viable contender for these jobs, L.B.G. needed more speed, versatility and capabilities than its six VMCs could provide. Machining the new parts would have taken considerably more time on the VMCs, and the geometric tolerances of the Inconel part would have been too close to maintain if it had to be moved from vise to vise to complete all sides. In search of a more efficient and cost-effective option, Mr. Heisner purchased a Doosan Infracore model HC 400 high-performance HMC from Precision Machine Tool Solutions, a regional Doosan distributor.
Standard features of the HC 400 include FANUC controls, an automatic pallet changer, and an all-axis guideway designed to increase speed, accuracy and productivity. Tool transfer time is 1.5 seconds or less for tools weighing less than 7.5 kilograms. The machine is capable of Y-axis rapid traverses of 40 meters per minute (131.2 feet per minute), and the 400- by 400-millimeter (15.7- by 15.7-inch) table can handle a maximum load of 400 kilograms (881.8 pounds).
According to Mr. Heisner, the HMC’s added capacity was a leading factor in L.B.G. winning both long-term contracts, plus other high-productivity, high-precision jobs. In fact, less than a year after the HMC was installed, the company purchased a second HC 400 to accommodate new precision machining work from a customer that manufactures firearms. The speed and efficiency of the HMCs have enabled Mr. Heisner to shift his manufacturing base to more multifaceted parts cut from a variety of metals, including Inconel, 416 stainless steel, 4140 heat-treated steel, and various grades of aluminum.
Originally, Mr. Heisner planned to use the first HMC to improve his manufacturing process and reduce cycle times on parts he was cutting on VMCs for longtime customers—parts for filtration equipment and pneumatic and pharmaceutical machinery. However, he has not yet shifted any of these jobs from the verticals to the horizontals. “We’ve just been so been overwhelmed by the volume of new work we’ve been getting,” he says.
According to Mr. Heisner, if the shop were to slow down or lose any work on the horizontals, he could easily move some of the jobs currently running on the verticals. “Even if a job can be done on a vertical, in a lot of cases, it can be done more efficiently and competitively on a horizontal,” he says. “We can get at more sides of the part.”
With their 60-tool magazines, the Doosan HMCs require less loading and fewer tool changes than a VMC, an attribute that enables the company to keep jobs set up. For repetitive parts, machine operators just snap in new jaws. In fact, setup on an HMC can be as much as 90 percent faster than on the company’s VMCs. As an added benefit, the tombstone rotates, so operators can fixture more blanks than on a VMC, Mr. Heisner says.
Each HMC is equipped with two tables to further maximize production. While one table is running a job, the other can be loaded (fixtured) or unloaded. The company mounted a four-sided fixture, manufactured by Chick Workholding Solutions (Warrendale, Pennsylvania), on
each pallet. The fixture features eight sets of jaws, which enable the programmer to maximize production based on the size, shape, quantity and type of machining operation. Most of L.B.G.’s jobs yield four, eight or even 16 completed parts every time the tables change stations.
Mr. Heisner currently runs his machines in three shifts, 24 hours a day. A single technician can operate both HMCs while performing other operations, such as deburring parts. While some deburring is done by hand and in a tumbler, deburring on the HMC is more efficient. Gravity makes chip removal easier with the horizontal spindle orientation.
If there is one drawback to a horizontal, it is that the initial setup takes longer and requires more skill than a VMC, Mr. Heisner says. It requires operators and programmers to think in terms of multisided fixture versatility concerning pallets and machining parts. However, once the machine is set up, it is highly productive, he says.
The horizontals have given employees the chance to improve their expertise, which Mr. Heisner says has helped L.B.G. take on advanced product lines that demand more from the company’s programmers and operators. For instance, the company is doing more four-axis programming and indexing for complex machining operations that require tight tolerances.
With the right equipment and employee know-how, L.B.G. Machine has been able to build its business. In fact, Mr. Heisner says he plans to purchase more HMCs to keep up with anticipated customer demand.
“Manufacturing in this country is now all about high productivity and precision,” he says. “We want to take whatever steps are necessary to position our shop competitively. We’re always trying to plan for the future to increase our capabilities, efficiency and productivity. Each time we add capabilities, we start looking ahead to our next move.”
When this aerospace job shop settled on machining tungsten alloys and other heavy metals as its specialty, it had to have a machine tool, cutting tools, workholding and process know-how to succeed.
Years of trial and error combined with the appropriate machining technology allow this company to produce custom parts made of alumina, zirconia, boron nitride and other advanced ceramic materials. One example of key machining technology is a five-axis machining center used exclusively to produce the complex, tightly toleranced geometry that fire-hardened workpieces require.
The force that holds the toolholder in the machining center's spindle can weaken over time. If you haven't checked drawbar force in a while, this may be the weak link in your process.