YCM Alliance
Published

Theory and Practice of the Shop Visit

There is certain information that can only come from standing in the facility.

Share

Earlier this year, I celebrated 20 years as an editor with Modern Machine Shop. A lot has changed in that time. North American machining facilities have become more sophisticated, changing the type of information their leaders need from us. Meanwhile, the avenues of information and the demands on our audience members’ attention have expanded as well. We (the MMS staff) are more acutely aware than ever of the importance of delivering value in what we post and publish.

But one thing has not changed, something distinctive about MMS when I joined it that remains distinctive today. Namely, we retain our emphasis on what we internally call “shop visits.” These are stories about an idea or technology that we research by taking a plane or car to the very facility where it is being used, so we can see it in action and talk to the people using it.

Researching a story this way entails a lot of trouble. The travel time generally exceeds the time at the site. Certainly there are other ways—we could go directly to the suppliers of the technology rather than the users; we could talk to the users by phone. We routinely do both these things.

But there are problems. The suppliers producing the technology are understandably bullish about it. Perspectives they share relate to the best-case promise. It is the users who discover what practical obstacles stand in the way. Meanwhile, though, those users also tend to be bullish. On the phone—again, understandably—the user will generalize for the sake of an efficient conversation. Only the in-person visit provides the time and context for exploring how the technology is really playing out. It offers the chance to witness a detail that doesn’t seem to fit the portrayal and ask, “So what’s going on there?” Genuine understanding often comes after this.

This kind of effort leads to stories that are messier and less dramatic than they might otherwise be. The 40-percent productivity improvement promised might actually be an 8-percent improvement as things have played out so far. That doesn’t mean the 40 percent misrepresented the matter, and there is value in the 8 percent, but there are reasons why the user has succeeded to one extent instead of the other. Explaining or at least giving a nod to all the factors in play results in a story that is more shaded and takes more words to tell. Not to mention: The story is also prone to be less attractive on the surface, because instead of relying on catalog photos, we take real photos of where the idea or technology is really being used.

The result is a sometimes quirky magazine featuring articles that look different and read differently from what is typical of a great many other industry publications. Yet contained within those differences is detail meaningful to the audience we serve, detail that wouldn’t come out any other way. So, it’s my intention that shop visits and the types of articles that result will always remain part of the way we produce this magazine, and any quirkiness is a price we’ll happily pay.

SW North America, CNC Machines and Automation
Campro USA
YCM Alliance
IMTS+
Koma Precision
Innovative Manufacturing for the Medical Industry
KraussMaffei
Techspex
Hurco
Paperless Parts
DN Solutions
QualiChem Metalworking Fluids

Related Content

Turning Machines

CNC Machine Shop Honored for Automation, Machine Monitoring

From cobots to machine monitoring, this Top Shop honoree shows that machining technology is about more than the machine tool.

Read More
Sponsored

Lean Approach to Automated Machine Tending Delivers Quicker Paths to Success

Almost any shop can automate at least some of its production, even in low-volume, high-mix applications. The key to getting started is finding the simplest solutions that fit your requirements. It helps to work with an automation partner that understands your needs.

Read More

An Additive Manufacturing Machine Shop

Finish machining additively manufactured implants requires different pacing and workflow than cutting parts from stock — different enough for an experienced manufacturer to warrant a dedicated machine shop.

Read More

Ballbar Testing Benefits Low-Volume Manufacturing

Thanks to ballbar testing with a Renishaw QC20-W, the Autodesk Technology Centers now have more confidence in their machine tools.

Read More

Read Next

View From My Shop

Inside Machineosaurus: Unique Job Shop with Dinosaur-Named CNC Machines, Four-Day Workweek & High-Precision Machining

Take a tour of Machineosaurus, a Massachusetts machine shop where every CNC machine is named after a dinosaur! 

Read More
Machines

IMTS 2024: Trends & Takeaways From the Modern Machine Shop Editorial Team

The Modern Machine Shop editorial team highlights their takeaways from IMTS 2024 in a video recap.

Read More
Sponsored

The Future of High Feed Milling in Modern Manufacturing

Achieve higher metal removal rates and enhanced predictability with ISCAR’s advanced high-feed milling tools — optimized for today’s competitive global market.

Read More
YCM Alliance