A Look at Additive Manufacturing in Minnesota
Increasing interest in 3D printing among machine shops was particularly conspicuous during a recent visit to multiple shops in Minneapolis, Minnesota.
Last December, I spent four days visiting seven CNC machine shops in and around Minneapolis, Minnesota. Something I found interesting is six of them are using 3D-printing equipment in some way.
One of those six shops is Monticello’s Ultra Machining Company (UMC), which primarily serves the aerospace and medical markets. UMC purchased its 3D printer in 2014, a Stratasys Fortus, that prints parts in acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) polymer.
UMC uses its printer in various ways. During the quoting and design for manufacturability stages, it commonly 3D prints prototypes for the new job. This is, perhaps, the most common use of plastic 3D printers among machine shops. Engineering Manager Corey Fouquette says this gives UMC a better idea of how to best fixture the part on a machine, helps identify areas where cutting tool or spindle clearance might be an issue, helps determine the best way for a tool to approach a certain feature to be machined, and so on. “Some of this you can glean by examining the part’s 3D CAD model, but we often find it more beneficial to have something physical to hold and manipulate by hand,” he notes. For large aerospace parts, UMC might 3D print them at a smaller scale.
The shop also 3D prints fixtures that secure parts to be measured on its coordinate measuring machine. One example I saw was a two-piece fixture featuring a base and hinged door. Once the part is installed in the fixture base, the door is closed around it and magnets keep it shut. Because it is made from polymer and not metal, it will not mar a part’s finish. This is important because those parts are machined for a medical application in which appearance is just as important as functionality.
Plus, turnaround time to 3D print the fixture is faster than making one from metal. “We can 3D print both components of this fixture at the same time in 24 hours,” Mr. Fouquette says. “It would take upwards of a week to make this out of metal when you consider the time it would take to obtain material, machine what would be five components, then assemble them.” The only assembly required for the polymer fixture is adding a pin to connect the door to the base. The print job is paused at a certain point to add the magnets, then printing continues, securing the magnets in the polymer.
Mr. Fouquette says UMC’s printer runs nearly 24/7. That certainly was not the case early on. “Our employees pretty much ignored it at first,” he says. “However, we launched an engineering internship program about the time we purchased the printer. Although those college juniors and seniors were ‘green’ when it came to conventional machining and manufacturing approaches, they really took to the 3D printer. They were designing and printing parts within a matter of days.”
In fact, the students solved a problem the shop was having protecting certain areas of a part during grit blasting. Their idea was to 3D print molds to create rubber masks to protect the areas of the part that did not call for an abrasive surface finish.
“Our seasoned employees saw what those ‘inexperienced’ young people were doing with our 3D printer, and that spurred them to learn how to use it and how to benefit from it,” Mr. Fouquette says. “That’s the key. You have to ingrain 3D printing into your shop’s culture.”
A video from Pratt & Whitney illustrates the steps needed to additively manufacture an aerospace component.
Three major technological advancements have changed modern manufacturing. Pay attention or get left behind.
Manufacturers now succeeding with additive manufacturing are beginning to see what its ultimate impact might be. Here are ideas about the reach that AM will have, and the kinds of changes and advances it will enable.